Death of a Bookkeeper
Part Four (The FBI's War on the Black Panthers)
In the mid-1970s, when we were reporters at Rolling Stone, Lowell Bergman and I decided to take am in-depth look into the FBI’s COINTELPRO campaign to disrupt progressive organizations. We focused first on the Black Panther Party.
In a 1967 memorandum, FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover, had stated that the program’s intent was to “expose, disrupt, misdirect, discredit, or otherwise neutralize the activities of black nationalists.”
By September 1968, the Panthers had emerged as the leading edge of the black power movement in the U.S. A key FBI memo solicited suggestions from its field agents for new ways to “create factionalism between not only the national leaders but also local leaders, steps to neutralize all organizational efforts of the (Panthers), as well as create suspicion amongst the leaders as to each other’s sources of finances, suspicion concerning their respective spouses and suspicion as to who may be cooperating with law enforcement.”
In another memo, in July 1969, Hoover declared that the Panthers were “without question the greatest threat to the internal security of the country.”
Starting late in 1968, there were numerous police raids on Panther offices around the country; sometimes including federal law enforcement officials. Several Panther leaders were killed or wounded, many others were sent to prison, or fled into exile.
In the course of gathering documents under the Freedom of Information Act and interviewing Panthers and ex-Panthers, including Eldridge Cleaver and Elaine Brown, Bergman and I were able to document hundreds of actions taken by FBI agents in pursuit of Hoover’s stated goals.
Many of these involved “disinformation,” sending letters purportedly from Cleaver to Huey Newton, for example, or vice versa, promoting the growing paranoia and distrust that already was driving the two leaders toward an eventual split.
I interviewed Elaine Brown during this period. She was the head of the party, as Newton was still in Cuba. She was smart, articulate and projected a sense of power.
“The government didn’t succeed in destroying us,” Brown told me. “We survived…These motherfuckers intended to kill every one of us. But it’s too late now. Our ideas are out there –- they cannot be erased from the minds of the people.”
After months of work, Bergman and I produced a story that presented an exhaustive catalogue of the federal government’s war against the Panthers. We also noted that the FBI’s relentless attempts to disrupt the organization “encouraged local police departments to harass the group” as well.
But the process of reviewing a huge number of law enforcement files had also exposed to us evidence suggesting there was a sinister side to the Panthers, including internecine violence that had nothing to do with government provocation but was more like ruthless gang activity.
In 1977, once we had founded the Center for Investigative Reporting and opened an office in Oakland, we received numerous complaints from people in that community that the Panthers were by then “out of control.” Several Panther sources stated that Newton in particular was wreaking havoc inside the inner-city neighborhoods by committing random violent assaults, often fueled by consuming alcohol and cocaine at the same time.
We decided that CIR should look into these allegations, and the result in 1978 was a long investigative article called “The Party’s Over,” by a courageous Berkeley journalist, Kate Coleman, and a veteran police reporter, Paul Avery, published in New Times magazine.
(Avery was later portrayed by Robert Downey Jr. in the 2007 Hollywood movie “Zodiac” for his work on the unsolved case of a notorious serial killer in the San Francisco Bay Area.)
Their article, “The Party’s Over,” documented dozens of violent incidents caused by Newton and his “security squad” against members of the party who had provoked Newton’s wrath, as well as non-party members, including a prostitute he killed, a tailor he pistol-whipped to the verge of death, and other random victims of his rage.
CIR was heavily criticized by the left for doing this story, but I’d long since grown used to such reactions from the PC crowd. We were journalists, not political partisans, so naturally both political extremes hated us for exposing their dirty secrets. It came with the territory.
As they were pursuing the investigation, Coleman and Avery had come upon the unsolved murder of Betty Van Patter, and thanks to Avery’s connections, gained access to the Berkeley Police Department file on the case.
Quoting that file:
“11:30 a.m. January 17th, 1975: Sgt. R. Scofield, piloting San Mateo County Sheriff’s Helicopter 2-H-10, was on patrol above San Francisco Bay when he spotted a body floating about a mile south of the San Mateo Hayward Bridge, between markers 670 and 680.
“He immediately put out distress calls to the U.S. Coast Guard, the Foster City Police Department, and the San Mateo Coroner’s Office. Within 15 minutes, the Coast Guard was on the scene, recovered the body, and took it to Old Warder Pier, on the corner of East Hillsdale Avenue and Teal Street, where representatives of the police department and coroner’s office quickly gathered.
“The medical examiner observed that the body was that of an adult female in a state of “moderate to severe post-mortem decomposition.”
“The remains were transported to Chope Hospital for an examination and identification. The body was placed in container #7 and sealed at 2:05 p.m. An autopsy was scheduled for 10 a.m. the following morning.”
It took three days for the coroner to determine an identity through the use of dental charts, but there was little doubt about the cause of death. The victim had been murdered -- killed by a massive blow to the head -- a “fractured calvarium” is noted in the autopsy report.
There was no water in the woman’s lungs, which means she was dead before her body got into the bay. The coroner estimated she was in the water for around three weeks, drifting on the currents, back and forth along the tide lines.
She was identified as Betty Van Patter.
(Part Five will appear tomorrow.)
HEADLINES:
US adviser and Palestinian Authority president to discuss plans for Gaza Strip (Guardian)
Biden envoy will meet with Abbas as the US floats a possible Palestinian security role in postwar Gaza (AP)
‘Elephant in the room’: The US military’s devastating carbon footprint (Al Jazeera)
How American citizens are leading rise of ‘settler violence’ on Palestinian lands (Guardian)
Rudy Giuliani ordered to pay $148M to Georgia poll workers (WP)
Hungary blocks €50bn of EU funding for Ukraine (BBC)
EU vows to fund Ukraine despite Hungary veto (Financial Times)
How the US keeps funding Ukraine’s military — even as it says it’s out of money (AP)
Western officials warn Ukraine is ‘certain to fail’ against Russia if US doesn’t provide more aid (CNN)
US Ally's Ominous Warning About China Flashpoint (Newsweek)
COP28 climate deal 'stab in the back', activist Greta Thunberg says (Reuters)
Government shutdown in January looms as Congress looks to head home (WP)
Republicans struggle as they keep getting forced to talk about abortion (Politico)
San Francisco’s Woes Are Well Known. Across the Bay, Oakland Has Struggled More. (NYT)
That Texas Abortion Case Is Even Worse Than You Think (Time)
Supreme Court leaves Illinois semiautomatic gun ban in place (NPR)
Sex and the Cities: More women live in major East Coast counties while men outnumber them in the West (AP)
What our data show about bias in American media (Economist)
E-books are fast becoming tools of corporate surveillance (Fast Company)
AI scientists make ‘exciting’ discovery using chatbots to solve maths problems (Guardian)
AI chatbot got election info wrong 30 percent of time, European study finds (WP)
Microsoft’s AI Chatbot Replies to Election Questions With Conspiracies, Fake Scandals, and Lies (Wired)
Stressed-Out 8-Year-Old Looks 12 (The Onion)
Excellent reporting on an important story David., no matter how long ago. More!
The fright & horror she went through!!!!!! Thank you for all your important work on so many historic stories!