Death of a Bookkeeper

Part Two

Betty Van Patter was a 45-year-old Black Panther Party bookkeeper and idealist who admired the party and its programs to fight racism and help the poor.

But somebody killed her and despite many clues and much evidence the mystery has remained unsolved for 49 years.

Meanwhile, over the course of my 58 years in journalism, I have worked on a lot of big stories. We got some of them, we didn’t get others, and I have a few regrets.

The Betty Van Patter case is one of my major regrets. The Alameda District Attorney, the Berkeley Police Department, several private investigators, and a number of other journalists are among those who have looked into the case and come up empty.

Some of the best work on the case has been done by investigative reporter Kate Coleman, who published one plausible scenario for Betty’s murder in the now defunct magazine Heterodoxy in 1994. Coleman revealed that the well-known private investigator David Fechheimer, who was working for the Panthers at the time of Betty’s murder, told his mentor, the legendary private eye Hal Lipset, who it was inside the Panthers who ordered Betty’s murder and who carried it out.

Lipset was working for Van Patter’s family at the time and he confirmed Coleman’s report to me. Both Lipset and Fechheimer have since died.

Yet nobody has ever been charged in the case. 

By now, interest by law enforcement and the media has all but vanished. The problem with this as a story is obvious. Historians, academics, young activists and old activists alike want to be able to celebrate the positive legacy of the Black Panthers, which includes exposing systematic racism, the harassment and arrest of countless black people, as well as the poverty and oppressive living conditions endured by millions to this day.

I want that too.

The issue is that to honestly tell the story of what happened to Betty Van Patter may seem to some to run counter to the ideal narrative, because it brings up the Panthers’ internal corruption, violence, sexism, prostitution, drugs, shakedowns, weaponry and justification of gratuitous violence.

All of which are just as true as the good stuff.

Therefore, any honest appraisal of the group’s place in history must first be capable of holding both sides of the truth in one hand, both the good and the bad, unflinchingly.

And for that, Betty’s case must be solved.

(Part Three appears tomorrow.)

Part One.

HEADLINES:

• Tesla recalls nearly all vehicles on US roads over lack of Autopilot safeguards (Reuters)

• House authorizes impeachment inquiry as Biden decries ‘baseless political stunt’ (Guardian)

• Dow Jones hits an all-time high as investors cheer progress on inflation (WP)

• Gaza: Israeli commanders among nine soldiers killed in Hamas ambush (Guardian)

• Netanyahu vows to block Palestinian Authority from Gaza rule (The Hill)

• Biden Warns Israel It Is ‘Losing Support’ Over War (NYT)

• In Dueling Remarks, Biden and Netanyahu Spar Over Gaza’s Future (WSJ)

• Israel Begins Flooding Hamas’ Tunnels in Gaza With Seawater (Daily Beast)

• 'Title 42 on steroids': Democrats consider expanding migrant detention and deportation in order to pass Ukraine aid (NBC)

• Ballistic missiles hit Kyiv, injuring more than 50 (WP)

• Jack Smith's Supreme Court appeal puts Trump in tough spot (MSNBC)

• Donald Trump's Trading Cards Are Plummeting in Value (Newsweek)

• Inside Trump’s Plot to Corrupt the 2024 Election With ‘Garbage’ Data (Rolling Stone)

• A majority of Americans agree with Biden on issues including abortion rights, capping insulin prices and hiking taxes on billionaires, a Reuters/Ipsos poll found, but his campaign faces a tough task in getting angry voters to care. (Reuters)

• Supreme Court will decide access to key abortion drug mifepristone (WP)

• What the COP28 deal means for the U.S. as oil and gas production hits record levels (CNBC)

• Minneapolis Man Is Freed After Serving 19 Years on Murder Charge (NYT)

• China-Philippines maritime standoff escalating on path that could drag US into conflict, analysts warn (CNN)

• The heartless treatment of Kate Cox in Texas (WP)

• The Republican abortion message out of Texas is clear: Judges, not doctors, know best (USA Today)

• Pregnant women take a leading role in new legal battles over abortion (WP)

• Revenue at Elon Musk’s X Falling at Alarming Rate: Report (Daily Beast)

• Elon Musk is going down a conspiratorial rabbit hole and taking X with him (CNN)

• Netflix reveals what people are really watching (WP)

• Draymond Green suspended indefinitely by NBA (NBA)

• The AI revolution in chemistry is not that far away (Nature)

• With AI Studio, Google launches an easy-to-use tool for developing apps and chatbots based on its Gemini model (TechCrunch)

• Tesla's latest Optimus robot can handle an egg without breaking it (Engadget)

• Biden Announces Plans For Extra PlayStation 5 Controller In Case Someone Visits Nation (The Onion)